Wednesday 30 May 2012

Are Creative Writing Courses A Waste of Time?



A couple of years ago journalist Lisa Pryor created a bit of an uproar in Australia with an article about creative writing courses in universities. The gist of her argument was that "if you can't work out what good writing is by reading widely, if you need it spelled out slowly with the benefit of a circle of plastic chairs and a whiteboard, you lack the mettle to be a great novelist."

She also claimed that university degrees in creative writing attract "those who are everything a good writer is not: compliant, institution bound and approval seeking. Thirdly, and most importantly, good writers risk becoming institutionalised."

Pryor echoed the belief many share that writing is not something that can be taught in the same way that other creative skills can be. Rarely do you hear people railing against the teaching of painting or sculpture at university level, but it seems writing is considered an inate ability that is best nurtured through starvation in an attic.

I have several problems with this article, not least of which is the claim that university writing courses will lead to "compliant, institution bound writers" who "other-think things." As if thinking and writing are mutually exclusive! During my years studying English and media studies at university I was trained to be anything but compliant and approval-seeking. A good university education teaches people to be critical thinkers and not accept things at face value. To claim these are not good skills for a writer to develop is ludicrous.

Obviously formal training is not required for people to become great writers, but it sure doesn't hurt. I've recently reached a point with my own writing where I don't feel I can go any further without some feedback and guidance. I hope to get accepted into a graduate certificate in creative writing in the near future. I really thrive on formal education and even though it's going to plunge me into thousands of dollars more debt with the tax man, it's worth it for me.

Here's a really interesting article by Jeanette Winterson about the explosion in the number of people who consider themselves writers and the increase in university creative writing courses. She shares Pryor's concern that these courses will create homogenised writers, but she is also hopeful that "this movement towards creativity and self-expression is really the start of a kind of Occupy – that it could be dangerous and confrontational, not homogenised at all."

She asks: "Is the world of work plus the leisure offerings of mass entertainment now so banal and unsatisfying that creative writing offers a fight-back? If the society we are making – that is, the society unelected big business is making for us – is both soulless and soul destroying, then micro solutions such as creative writing could return some sense of both individuality and community."

This is a really interesting way of looking at the increase in creative writing courses and self-publishing, and it is a refreshing change from most articles you will find on these subjects. Maybe I'm hopelessly optimistic and romantic, but I do believe there is something to be gained for society as a whole as more people get the opportunity to creatively express themselves.

11 comments:

  1. I'm currently in a sort of in-between course. I'm studying Journalism, Media, and Cultural studies so while still writing related it does not exactly teach me how to be a better fiction writer. But in general I think no one should look down on the way someone learns their craft - it it is a writing course or suffering in an attic! Whichever way works for you :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Katharina, your course will definitely help improve your writing skills, and it provides a good stepping-stone to creative writing courses at postgrad level if you choose to go in that direction. Sometimes I wish I'd saved myself a lot of money and gone straight into a writing degree, but the journey through a range of courses has been a lot of fun.

      Delete
  2. I really enjoyed reading this post. I am currently working towards a B.A in English and one of my elective classes is a creative writing course. While I don' t do much personal writing, I would love to mess around with my own writing just to see what I can do with it. I am very excited to take a class on writing because I want the criticism from my peers and mentors. Also, I am hoping my professor will introduce me to some new forms or prompts that I may not have been exposed to yet.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did a BA in English also and started a creative writing course in my first year but found it daunting having to read my work out to the class so i dropped out. I hope you get a lot out of your class because it really is a great opportunity to get feedback and advice.

      Delete
  3. I don't think any form of learning is bad so long as you're taking something positive out of it. I have a friend who just completed a creative writing course. Prior to the course she'd ask generalized questions about my stories in the same way that most people do. By the end of the course she was more aware and asked me more critical, analytic questions!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Any kind of course which makes you look more closely and critically at your writing has got to help! Sounds like your friends's course helped her quite a bit.

      Delete
  4. Wow, great and really interesting post you have written here, I agree with mostly everything that you have said :)

    - Alex @ Possession of Books

    ReplyDelete
  5. My experience with writing courses has been generally negative. I know a lot of people have had good experiences with them. I learned more from my critique group (http://www.writingsnippets.com/)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Maybe creative writing courses aren't as beneficial for some people as they would like them to be, but they definately couldn't hurt! There are always new things to learn, and everyone's work can always be improved! :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have tagged you to recieve the Liebster blog award
    Have a look at my blog for info

    http://nikorachan.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi, nice post. Well what can I say is that these is an interesting and very informative topic. Thanks for sharing your ideas, its not just entertaining but also gives your reader knowledge. Good blogs style too, Cheers!

    - The Writing Courses Pittsburgh PA

    ReplyDelete